UPSC CSE 2027Prelims in 187 daysMains in 276 days

Examine whether the constitutional office of the Lok Sabha Speaker has become vulnerable to partisan politics under the current anti-defection regime. What institutional changes are required to ensure neutrality? (2026, 10 Marks)

PaperGS Paper 2
Word Limit150 words
Syllabus TopicIndian Polity – Parliament; Anti-Defection Law

Lok Sabha Speaker and anti-defection law UPSC GS2 2026 model answer

Lok Sabha Speaker and Anti-Defection Law: Model Answer

The Lok Sabha Speaker is the impartial guardian of the House. Under the Tenth Schedule (1985), the Speaker also decides disqualification of defectors. This makes the office open to partisan pressure, because the Speaker is usually elected from the ruling party.

Speaker elected by majority Decides disqualification (Para 6) Need: independent tribunal

Why neutrality is at risk

Vulnerabilities

  • Para 6 makes the Speaker the final authority on disqualification.
  • Delay in deciding petitions can protect defectors for years.
  • The Speaker may remain a party member, so the office is seen as partisan.

Institutional Changes

  • In Keisham Meghachandra Singh (2020), the Supreme Court asked Parliament to consider a permanent tribunal and said Speakers should decide within three months.
  • Follow the UK convention: the Speaker quits party politics and is returned unopposed.
  • Let the President or Governor decide on the Election Commission’s advice (Dinesh Goswami Committee).

Conclusion

The Speaker’s authority rests on trust. Time-bound, independent decisions will protect parliamentary democracy and the basic structure.

Value Addition: Speaker and Anti-Defection Facts

  • The Tenth Schedule was added by the 52nd Amendment (1985). The 91st Amendment (2003) removed the “one-third split” exception and capped the Council of Ministers at 15 per cent of the House.
  • Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu (1992): the Supreme Court upheld Para 6 but held that the Speaker’s decision is open to judicial review, and struck down the bar on courts in Para 7.
  • The Speaker is elected by the House (Article 93). Removal needs a resolution passed by a majority of all the then members, with 14 days’ notice (Articles 94 and 96). The Speaker cannot preside while such a resolution is pending.
  • Defection grounds include voluntarily giving up party membership and defying the party whip in a vote. A merger of two-thirds of the legislature party is protected.
  • Read how Parliament and the cabinet interact in our answer on cabinet system and parliamentary supremacy, and on electoral reforms.
  • For official texts, see the Parliament of India website.

Related PYQs

FAQs on the Lok Sabha Speaker

Which GS paper covers the Speaker and anti-defection law?

GS Paper 2 (Indian Polity: Parliament and Constitutional Amendments).

Which Schedule contains the anti-defection law?

The Tenth Schedule, added by the 52nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1985.

Can courts review the Speaker’s decision on disqualification?

Yes. In Kihoto Hollohan (1992), the Supreme Court held that the Speaker’s decision is subject to judicial review.

How can the Speaker be removed?

By a resolution passed by a majority of all the then members of the Lok Sabha, after 14 days’ notice (Article 94).

Topic notes: Parliament UPSC GS2

✍️ Wrote your own answer to this question?

Upload it and get it evaluated instantly, with examiner-style red-ink remarks and marks.

Upload your answer →

Or join our free daily answer-writing group on Telegram

For GS2 aspirants

Practise every GS2 PYQ, theme-wise

GS2 Mains PYQ workbooks: Polity, Governance, Social Justice and IR (3 PDFs)

View the workbook →
GS

Dr. Gaurav J. Sontake

Mentoring UPSC aspirants since 2020 · 10,000+ students · Former answer evaluator, Vision IAS

Not sure if your strategy is working? Talk it through on a free first mentorship call.

📅 Book a free call on WhatsApp

Helpline: 7827779142

Leave a Comment