UPSC CSE 2027Prelims in 182 daysMains in 271 days

Basic Structure Doctrine UPSC GS2: Cases and Notes

Quick answer (Basic structure doctrine UPSC GS2): The basic structure doctrine says Parliament can amend the Constitution under Article 368, but cannot change its core features. It came from Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) and is used to test amendments and laws.
PaperGS2 / Paper III (Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations)
Syllabus line“Indian Constitution- historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.” This post covers the basic structure.
Weightage (plain words)This site has two linked GS2 model answers close to this topic: judicial independence (2023) and the growth of PIL and the power of the Supreme Court (2024). There is no model answer yet with the basic structure as its direct subject, so no percentage is given. The doctrine is used in most answers on amendments and the judiciary.

Key concepts

The words “basic structure” do not appear in the Constitution. The doctrine was created by the Supreme Court to protect the core identity of the Constitution from changes by a temporary majority in Parliament.

1. How the doctrine developed

  • Shankari Prasad (1951) and Sajjan Singh (1965). The Court held that Parliament could amend any part of the Constitution, including fundamental rights.
  • Golak Nath v. State of Punjab (1967). An eleven-judge bench held by a 6 to 5 majority that Parliament could not amend fundamental rights.
  • 24th and 25th Amendments (1971). Parliament responded by stating that its amending power covered all provisions, and by limiting review of laws made to give effect to directive principles.
  • Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973). A bench of thirteen judges heard the case for 68 days. By a narrow 7 to 6 majority, the Court held that Parliament has wide power to amend, but cannot change the basic structure or framework of the Constitution. The Court did not give a full list of what the basic structure is.
  • Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975). The Court struck down a part of the 39th Amendment that put the election of the Prime Minister beyond court review. It held that free and fair elections, democracy and the rule of law are part of the basic structure.
  • Minerva Mills v. Union of India (1980). The Court struck down clauses of the 42nd Amendment that limited judicial review and gave Parliament unlimited power to amend. It held that the balance between fundamental rights and directive principles is part of the basic structure.
  • Waman Rao v. Union of India (1981). The Court held that the doctrine applies to amendments made after 24 April 1973, the date of the Kesavananda judgment.
  • S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994). The Court listed secularism and federalism as part of the basic structure, and made the use of Article 356 subject to judicial review.
  • L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997). The Court held that the power of judicial review of the Supreme Court and the High Courts under Articles 32, 226 and 227 is part of the basic structure, so tribunals cannot fully replace the High Courts.
  • I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu (2007). Laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 can be reviewed on the ground that they violate the basic structure.
  • Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (2015). The Court struck down the 99th Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, holding that independence of the judiciary is part of the basic structure.
  • Janhit Abhiyan v. Union of India (2022). By a 3 to 2 majority the Court upheld the 103rd Amendment on reservation for economically weaker sections, and held that it did not violate the basic structure.

2. Features the courts have treated as basic

The list is built case by case. The following have been accepted at different times:

  • Supremacy of the Constitution and rule of law.
  • Republican and democratic form of government, and sovereignty.
  • Secular character.
  • Federalism and the separation of powers.
  • Unity and integrity of the nation.
  • Judicial review and independence of the judiciary.
  • Free and fair elections.
  • Parliamentary system.
  • Balance between fundamental rights and directive principles.

3. Arguments in favour

  • It protects the identity of the Constitution when a strong majority wants to change it.
  • It gives the courts a basis to check misuse of the amending power, as in the case of the 39th Amendment.
  • It is flexible. The courts can decide new cases without rewriting the text.
  • It protects minorities and individuals from the majority.

4. Arguments against

  • The list is not fixed, so there is uncertainty about what is basic.
  • Unelected judges can strike down amendments passed by elected representatives. Critics call this judicial overreach.
  • The doctrine is not written in the Constitution, so it is a judge-made limit.
  • It may delay reforms that have wide support.

5. Common misunderstandings

  • It limits amendments, not ordinary laws. Ordinary laws are tested against the Constitution itself, including fundamental rights. The basic structure test is mainly used for constitutional amendments, and the Court has also applied it to laws placed in the Ninth Schedule.
  • It does not freeze the Constitution. Parliament can still amend almost every Article. The doctrine only blocks changes that damage the core identity.
  • It is not a power to rewrite. The Court strikes down or upholds an amendment. It does not draft a new one.
  • The effect counts, not the label. The Court looks at what an amendment actually does to the Constitution, and not only at the words used.

6. Why it matters now

The doctrine is the main reason why India has not seen the Constitution rewritten by one Parliament. It also explains the long debate between Parliament and the judiciary over appointment of judges, which led to the 2015 judgment on the NJAC. A good answer in the exam should show both sides: the doctrine guards democracy, but it also needs judicial restraint and clear reasoning, so that the courts do not take the place of the elected legislature.

7. Answer-writing tip

Write the doctrine in one line, then trace it through three cases: Golak Nath, Kesavananda Bharati and Minerva Mills. Add one recent case, such as the NJAC judgment or the EWS judgment. End with a balanced view on parliamentary sovereignty and judicial review.

Table and mnemonic

CaseYearWhat it held
Golak Nath1967Parliament cannot amend fundamental rights
Kesavananda Bharati1973Parliament cannot alter the basic structure
Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain1975Free and fair elections are basic
Minerva Mills1980Balance of rights and directive principles is basic; limits on judicial review struck down
S.R. Bommai1994Secularism and federalism are basic
I.R. Coelho2007Ninth Schedule laws after 24 April 1973 can be reviewed
Advocates-on-Record2015NJAC struck down; judicial independence is basic

Mnemonic: G-K-I-M-B. Golak Nath, Kesavananda, Indira Gandhi, Minerva, Bommai, the five cases in order.

How UPSC asks it

UPSC links the basic structure to judicial independence, the powers of the Supreme Court and the limits on Parliament. Two model answers on this site help you practise the connected themes.

3 practice questions

  1. What is the basic structure doctrine? Trace its development through landmark cases. (15 marks, 250 words)
  2. Does the basic structure doctrine strengthen democracy or limit it? Discuss. (10 marks, 150 words)
  3. The Supreme Court’s judgment on the NJAC raised questions on the balance between Parliament and the judiciary. Examine. (10 marks, 150 words)

Write your answers and get them checked: free answer evaluation.

FAQ

Is the basic structure written in the Constitution?

No. It is a doctrine developed by the Supreme Court.

Which case gave the basic structure doctrine?

Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, 1973.

What was the majority in Kesavananda Bharati?

7 to 6, by a bench of thirteen judges.

Is there a fixed list of basic features?

No. The list has grown case by case.

Read next

📞 Not sure your preparation strategy is working?

Talk it through on a free first mentorship call. Tell us where you are stuck, and get a clear next step.

📅 Book a free call on WhatsApp

Helpline: 7827779142

Practise daily, for free: join our Telegram answer-writing group or get an answer evaluated instantly.

By Dr. Gaurav J. Sontake · Mentoring UPSC aspirants since 2020 · 10,000+ students · Former answer evaluator, Vision IAS

Leave a Comment