UPSC CSE 2027Prelims in 182 daysMains in 271 days

Dispute Redressal Mechanisms UPSC GS2: Notes

Quick answer (Dispute redressal mechanisms UPSC GS2): India resolves disputes through courts, tribunals, inter-governmental bodies and alternative methods such as Lok Adalats, arbitration and mediation. Know the Articles (131, 262, 263, 323A), the main bodies and their limits.
PaperGS2 / Paper III (Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations)
Syllabus line“Separation of powers between various organs dispute redressal mechanisms and institutions.” This post covers dispute redressal mechanisms and institutions. Separation of powers has its own post.
Weightage (plain words)This site has two linked GS2 model answers that touch this topic: Lok Adalats and arbitration tribunals (2024) and dispute resolution in the federal framework (2026). That is a small sample, so no percentage is given.

Key concepts

A dispute can be between citizens, between a citizen and the State, between two States, or between the Centre and a State. India uses different institutions for each type. The aim is to give quick, low-cost and fair justice, and to reduce the load on regular courts.

1. Disputes between governments

  • Supreme Court, Article 131. The Supreme Court has exclusive original jurisdiction in disputes between the Centre and one or more States, or between States, if the dispute involves a question of law or fact on which the existence of a legal right depends.
  • Inter-State Council, Article 263. The President can set up a council to inquire into and advise on disputes between States, and on subjects of common interest. The Sarkaria Commission recommended a permanent council, and the Inter-State Council was set up in 1990.
  • Zonal Councils. These were created under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956. There are five councils, and the Union Home Minister is the chairman. They discuss common problems of States in a zone. They are advisory bodies.
  • River water disputes, Article 262. Parliament can make a law for the adjudication of disputes over the use, distribution or control of waters of an inter-State river. It can also bar the Supreme Court and other courts from deciding such disputes. The Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 provides for a tribunal when negotiation fails. The Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal gave its final award in 2007, and in 2018 the Supreme Court modified the allocation.

2. Disputes between citizens and the State

  • Writs, Articles 32 and 226. A person can go to the Supreme Court or a High Court for the enforcement of fundamental rights. High Courts can also issue writs for other legal rights.
  • Administrative tribunals, Article 323A. Parliament can create tribunals for service matters of public employees. The Central Administrative Tribunal was set up under the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985.
  • Tribunals for other matters, Article 323B. Parliament and State legislatures can create tribunals for taxation, land reforms, industrial disputes, elections to Parliament and State legislatures, and other listed matters.
  • Judicial review of tribunals. In L. Chandra Kumar (1997) the Supreme Court held that decisions of tribunals can be challenged before the High Courts, and that judicial review is part of the basic structure.
  • Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021. This law brought changes in the structure and service conditions of several tribunals and abolished some appellate tribunals.
  • National Green Tribunal. It was set up by the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 to decide environmental cases quickly.
  • Grievance systems. Departments have grievance officers, and the Centralised Public Grievance Redress and Monitoring System (CPGRAMS) lets citizens file complaints online.

3. Alternative dispute resolution (ADR)

  • Lok Adalats. They run under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, which follows Article 39A on equal justice and free legal aid. They settle cases by compromise. Their award is treated as a decree of a civil court, is final and cannot be appealed. They can deal with civil cases and with criminal cases that are compoundable. They cannot decide non-compoundable offences. Permanent Lok Adalats deal with public utility services.
  • Arbitration. The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 provides for private tribunals for civil and commercial disputes. The award is binding, and a court can set it aside only on limited grounds. Criminal cases are not decided by arbitration.
  • Mediation. The Mediation Act, 2023 gives a legal framework for mediation, which is a voluntary process led by a neutral person.
  • Gram Nyayalayas. The Gram Nyayalayas Act, 2008 provides for village-level courts to give justice at the doorstep of rural people.
  • Family courts and consumer commissions. The Family Courts Act, 1984 and the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (with District, State and National Commissions) give special forums for family and consumer matters.

4. Election disputes

  • Doubts and disputes about the election of the President and Vice-President are decided by the Supreme Court (Article 71).
  • Election petitions for Parliament and State legislatures are filed in the High Court under the Representation of the People Act, 1951.

5. Issues and the way forward

  • Delay. Tribunals and courts have heavy case loads, and tribunal vacancies are a concern.
  • Weak follow-up. Water tribunal awards are hard to implement when States do not agree.
  • Underuse of consultative bodies. The Inter-State Council and Zonal Councils are advisory, and their use depends on the political will of governments.
  • Independence of tribunals. The courts have raised concerns about appointments and service conditions.
  • Way forward. Give more regular meetings to the Inter-State Council, strengthen mediation, fill vacancies, use technology in courts, and build trust through cooperative federalism.

6. Answer-writing tip

Group the answer under three heads: disputes between governments, disputes between citizens and the State, and alternative methods. Give one Article or law under each head. End with the main problem, which is delay and weak implementation, and with two or three practical reforms.

Table and mnemonic

Type of disputeForumLegal basis
Centre and States, or between StatesSupreme CourtArticle 131
Inter-State river waterWater Disputes TribunalArticle 262 and Act of 1956
Policy and common issues of StatesInter-State Council, Zonal CouncilsArticle 263, States Reorganisation Act 1956
Service mattersAdministrative TribunalsArticle 323A, Act of 1985
Settlement by compromiseLok AdalatLegal Services Authorities Act 1987
Commercial disputesArbitrationAct of 1996

Mnemonic: G-C-A. Governments (Articles 131, 262, 263), Citizens (writs and tribunals), Alternatives (Lok Adalat, arbitration, mediation).

How UPSC asks it

UPSC asks about one forum in detail, or about dispute resolution as part of federalism. Two model answers on this site give you both patterns.

3 practice questions

  1. Distinguish between Lok Adalats and Permanent Lok Adalats. How do they reduce the burden on courts? (10 marks, 150 words)
  2. Examine the mechanisms for resolving inter-State river water disputes in India. Why are they often slow? (15 marks, 250 words)
  3. Tribunals have become an important part of the justice system, but concerns remain. Discuss. (15 marks, 250 words)

Write your answers and get them checked: free answer evaluation.

FAQ

Which Article gives the Supreme Court original jurisdiction in Centre-State disputes?

Article 131.

Can a Lok Adalat decide criminal cases?

Only compoundable criminal cases. Non-compoundable offences are outside its scope.

Is a Lok Adalat award appealable?

No. It is final and is treated as a civil court decree.

Which Article deals with inter-State river disputes?

Article 262.

Read next

📞 Not sure your preparation strategy is working?

Talk it through on a free first mentorship call. Tell us where you are stuck, and get a clear next step.

📅 Book a free call on WhatsApp

Helpline: 7827779142

Practise daily, for free: join our Telegram answer-writing group or get an answer evaluated instantly.

By Dr. Gaurav J. Sontake · Mentoring UPSC aspirants since 2020 · 10,000+ students · Former answer evaluator, Vision IAS

Leave a Comment