UPSC CSE 2027Prelims in 181 daysMains in 270 days

Indian Constitution Comparison UPSC GS2: Notes and PYQs

Quick answer (Indian Constitution comparison UPSC GS2): India has a written constitution that mixes ideas from the UK, the US, Ireland, Canada and others, but adapts them. It is a parliamentary, quasi-federal system with a strong Centre, a single citizenship and judicial review limited by the basic structure. UPSC asks for a feature-wise comparison, usually with the US or the UK.
PaperGS2 / Paper III (Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations)
Syllabus line“Comparison of the Indian constitutional scheme with that of other countries”
Weightage (plain words)This site has 3 linked GS2 PYQ model answers from 2023 to 2026 that compare India with other countries: secularism with the US, separation of powers and the PM with the US President, and parliamentary sovereignty with Britain. Questions usually ask for a comparison on one feature.

Key concepts

You cannot compare everything. In Mains, pick one feature, take two or three comparison points and give a clear conclusion. This post gives you the base facts.

1. Sources of the Indian Constitution

  • The Constituent Assembly first met in December 1946, adopted the Constitution on 26 November 1949, and it came into force on 26 January 1950. It originally had 395 Articles, 22 Parts and 8 Schedules.
  • The Government of India Act, 1935 is the biggest single source. The federal scheme, the office of Governor, emergency provisions, Public Service Commissions and much of the administrative detail come from it.
  • The framers also borrowed ideas from other countries and adapted them to Indian conditions. Do not present them as copied.

2. Commonly listed borrowings

  • UK: parliamentary government, Cabinet system, rule of law, single citizenship, bicameralism, the office of the Speaker and writs.
  • USA: Fundamental Rights, judicial review, independent judiciary, the Preamble, impeachment of the President and the Vice-President as chairman of the Rajya Sabha.
  • Ireland: Directive Principles of State Policy, nomination of members to the Rajya Sabha and the method of electing the President.
  • Canada: a federation with a strong Centre, residuary powers with the Centre, appointment of Governors by the Centre and the advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
  • Australia: the Concurrent List, freedom of trade and commerce and the joint sitting of the two Houses.
  • Weimar Germany: suspension of Fundamental Rights during an Emergency.
  • USSR: Fundamental Duties and the ideal of justice in the Preamble.
  • France: the republic and the ideals of liberty, equality and fraternity.
  • South Africa: the amendment procedure and election of Rajya Sabha members by MLAs.
  • Japan: the phrase “procedure established by law”.

3. India and the USA

  • Federalism: the US federation was formed by agreement among States. In India, Article 1 calls the country a “Union of States”. Dr. Ambedkar explained that the Indian federation is not the result of an agreement among States and that no State can secede. Parliament can change State boundaries under Article 3 without needing the State’s consent for the final decision.
  • Union bias: India has a single citizenship, an integrated judiciary, All India Services, Governors appointed by the Centre and emergency powers. The US has State constitutions and separate State court systems.
  • Executive: the US has a presidential system with a fixed term. India has a parliamentary system where the real executive is the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister, collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. The President acts on aid and advice under Article 74.
  • Judiciary: the US Supreme Court established judicial review in Marbury v. Madison (1803). India also has judicial review, and the basic structure doctrine from Kesavananda Bharati (1973) limits even constitutional amendments.
  • Rights: the US Bill of Rights (1791) is mainly in the first ten amendments. India has Fundamental Rights with reasonable restrictions, Directive Principles and Fundamental Duties (added by the 42nd Amendment, 1976).
  • Secularism: the US First Amendment bars the State from establishing a religion and is read as a strong wall between State and religion. India follows principled distance: the State can regulate and reform religious practice (Article 25(2)) while respecting all faiths.

4. India and the UK

  • Constitution: the UK constitution is uncodified. India has a written constitution.
  • Sovereignty: Parliament is sovereign in the UK. In India, Parliament is bound by the Constitution, and courts can strike down laws.
  • Head of State: the UK has a hereditary monarch. India has a President elected indirectly by an electoral college (Article 54), using proportional representation by single transferable vote (Article 55).
  • Second chamber: the House of Lords is not elected. The Rajya Sabha is indirectly elected and a permanent House, with one-third of members retiring every two years.
  • Speaker: in the UK, the Speaker gives up party links by convention. In India, the Speaker often stays a party member, which raises concerns about neutrality.
  • Common ground: both follow the Cabinet system and the principle that the executive is responsible to the lower House.

5. Other countries in short

  • Canada: a federation with a strong Centre, closest to the Indian model.
  • Australia: a concurrent list and a federal system with States.
  • France: a semi-presidential system under the 1958 Constitution, with a directly elected President and a Prime Minister.
  • Switzerland: known for direct democracy tools such as referendums.
  • South Africa: a modern constitution with a strong Constitutional Court and a detailed bill of rights.

6. What is distinctive about India

  • Quasi-federal structure: federal in form, with a strong Centre in times of need. The Supreme Court in S.R. Bommai (1994) held that federalism is part of the basic structure.
  • Asymmetric federalism: special provisions for some States under Articles 371 to 371J and the Fifth and Sixth Schedules.
  • Mixed amendment process: Article 368 allows some amendments by special majority, some also need ratification by half of the States, and some changes (such as the creation of States under Article 3) need only a simple majority.
  • Rights and goals together: Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles are balanced. Minerva Mills (1980) said harmony between the two is part of the basic structure.
  • Universal adult franchise from the beginning, without any property or education test, unlike many older democracies.

7. Answer-writing tip

Choose three or four points such as federalism, executive, judiciary and rights. Use a table for the comparison. Then say what India has adapted, and give a short evaluation.

Table and mnemonic

FeatureIndiaUSAUK
Form of StateUnion of States with a strong CentreFederation by agreement of StatesUnitary
GovernmentParliamentaryPresidentialParliamentary
ConstitutionWritten, mixed amendment processWritten, rigid amendment processUncodified
Head of StateElected PresidentElected President (also head of government)Hereditary monarch
Judicial reviewYes, subject to basic structureStrongNo power to strike down Acts of Parliament
CitizenshipSingleFederal and StateSingle

Mnemonic: UK-US-I-CA-A. UK gave the Parliament and the Cabinet, US gave Rights and Review, Ireland gave Directives, CAnada gave the strong Centre, Australia gave the Concurrent List.

How UPSC asks it

UPSC picks one feature and one country. These model answers show the approach:

3 practice questions

  1. Compare the federal scheme of India with that of the USA. Why is India called a quasi-federal State? (15 marks, 250 words)
  2. Compare the role of the Speaker in India and the UK. Should India adopt the British practice? (10 marks, 150 words)
  3. The Indian Constitution is a bag of borrowings. Critically examine. (10 marks, 150 words)

Write your answers and get them checked: free answer evaluation.

FAQ

What is the biggest source of the Indian Constitution?

The Government of India Act, 1935, which gave the federal scheme, the Governor’s office, emergency provisions and administrative details.

Is India a federation like the USA?

Not exactly. Article 1 calls India a Union of States. It is federal in structure but has a strong Centre, a single citizenship and an integrated judiciary, so many call it quasi-federal.

Which countries gave the Directive Principles and the Concurrent List?

Directive Principles are linked to Ireland and the Concurrent List to Australia.

How is Indian judicial review different from the US?

Both have judicial review, but in India the Constitution itself limits parliamentary power through the basic structure doctrine, and Article 21 uses “procedure established by law”, which the Supreme Court has read in a wider way since Maneka Gandhi (1978).

Read next

📞 Not sure your preparation strategy is working?

Talk it through on a free first mentorship call. Tell us where you are stuck, and get a clear next step.

📅 Book a free call on WhatsApp

Helpline: 7827779142

Practise daily, for free: join our Telegram answer-writing group or get an answer evaluated instantly.

By Dr. Gaurav J. Sontake · Mentoring UPSC aspirants since 2020 · 10,000+ students · Former answer evaluator, Vision IAS

Leave a Comment